signature competition #1 voting thread...

thanks, Lelou

1 vote per person I guess?

should we post CnC here too?
I think it's common to do so

Ohh...yeah forgot to add that...

My bad...

No one is voting

ok, here I go:

(1) always looking at the bright points, not at the render, they are just too distracting xD
and the text is too small to read (but I guess those aren't the actual sizes?)
Neat work though.

(2) I think that's the first sig of a train I've seen. +1000 points for humor and creativity, it's nicely placed, the smoke and background fit well, but it's a bit plain.
And it should be "Road to the future" if you don't mean a spacial location named "Future". lol

(3) Looks weird. The background has two colours, and saeko has a strange halo around her head. The text looks a bit sloppy. the black swooshshooshthingy spreads a bit too far I think.

(4) Nice work. Rather mainstream, but safe way to make a sig I guess.
If anything, then then render should probably placed different, it looks too small, especially in width. Makes it look like you should just cut off a centimeter or two at the left and right, I would have cut the render off at the waist and made it bigger. Might be due to the resizing though, it could look better in original size.

Nice work, all of you! Thanks for your efforts xD

Voted for #1, seemed the most unique in my eyes, a bit of lighting trouble. Too many dominant light spots. Composition is interesting though.

#2
You covered most of the sig in smoke, it shows there wasn't much confidence for you composition. If you went over the basics of the software that was used I am sure you could make something unique and wonderful : )

#3
Too messy, tried to use too many things at once. I can see how you tried to provide flow in the sig but you also misdirected it with the background (I think blur was used on BG) and splats. Border stands out too much. It was initially a dark sig and I find it distracting. Change it to black or a colour that is very close and perhaps make it thinner. Text is nowhere near the focal and it's positioning needs more thought. Lighting?

#4
Brightness on the centre isn't justified by any light source. Text could do with some sharpening and the composition seems simple. Everything besides the render is slightly fuzzy. This sig is like a prostitute, looks nice but in a very sloppy and distasteful manner
... not much else to say :Z

dang i should've entered this!!!!!

1) Would've gotten my vote, the lighting was a bit off imo, to light for such darkness, if it was dark filter i would've totally voted for it!

2) Train? Lmao +1 for simplicity looks like someone just threw something in last minute and worked with it for a bit, looks nice, still though, if you can make a train look cool, i'd like to see something anime related.

3) I'm mean when i can't think of anything positive... and that's here... sorry just, dang there's work to do. and I'm not even that good!!!! Hate me i deserve it

4) Got my vote, friendly with for the eyes, and basics of the basics all nicely introduced, although once i stare at it long enough i can see the fuzzy background and the hd render sticking out like a sore thumb, still though my favorite of the bunch no doubt.

1) Too much lighting

2) Too Plain

3) C4D's need better placing

4) Dislike the text

Its a bit late but that ended with veiyla's crushing victory...